Lisa -S.H. wrote:Robin the Busker wrote:I'm sold on dddd.
Robin, you are using all thin gauge strings, like your melody string, right? no thick or wound strings? All same octave, same note?
Are you playing ionian mode in D by using the 6 1/2 fret while in that mixolydian mode tuning with the tonic on the open string?
Hi Lisa,
Yes - that is it exactly.
I have 4 x thin plain gauge strings all tuned to "d" in the same octave. I think that I have 2 x 0.013 (melody pair) and 2 x 0.012 (drone pair) on my Walnut Creek (27.5 VSL) at present plus I use a possum board that I built and a Dunlop nylon .73 pick (I think that I could do with a larger size pick, it is the next area to experiment with). The 4 strings are set equidistant and I use my noter across the first two strings leaving strings 3 and 4 as drones. From what I can work out, this is the system that Galax players like Phyllis Gaskins use. I have not yet found a feather to use - and I would like to try that strumming method out - but I know many modern Galax players have switched to a pick, so I think that I just need to find the right one for me.
For key of D fiddle tunes I play ionian in that mixolidian tuning using the 6+. Although I must say that many tunes acutally don't use that note.
For G I play ionian with the root at fret 3 across the two d,d drones.
For A (dorian/aeolian/mixolidian and ionian) I use a reverse capo at the first fret on the drones and the 6+ if required. Plus I use the "angled noter" technique to snatch the 7th of the scale in A ionian (say for a tune like Buffalow Gals) as only the mixolidian notes are avaialable with this tuning. The reverse capo worked well - it was very quick to fit and required no more than the tuning check adjust that I do after each tune anyway. For some ionian/mixolidian tunes in A, it is simpler just to just fit a full capo at the first fret (say for Cripple Creek) because you can then do a pull-off for the root note rather than jumping the noter down to it - it is just faster.
Th basic tuning of dddd remains the same throughout - I'm just using a half or full capo at the first fret (no higher) to access key of A tunes. With this system I seem to have pretty much every standard fiddle tune covered in the key that they are normally played at sessions.
I can just drop the 2nd string from d to A to give ddAd (bass to trebble) and still play all the DAd chord melody tunes I know. It is quite simple to mute the third string (the inner drone) while fretting the 4th string if the open d does not fit the chord you want to play. I played that version of "Soldiers Joy" that I posted earlier this week using this tuning. Last night I used this tuning for "Land of my Fathers" and it works fine for those quieter melodic pieces. Also, if you kick off "Land of my Fathers in a Welsh pub then the whole place falls silent so the loss of volume compared with the punch of noter/drone is not an issue

Like Robin T, I'm not sure why more players don't use this very versatile dddd tuning system with eqidistant spacing - virtually every MD has the bridge and nut cut for it - I had to make no modifications to my Walnut Creek. I can now certainly understand why it has a reputation as a "session" tuning for use when playing with other instruments.
The strangest thing is that I have just not noticed that the bass strings are not there? I think that the MD must naturally generate under-tones as well as over-tones?
Robin